The MLB postseason is reaching a fever pitch as teams fight to stay alive or seal their place in the next round. October 9 brings a packed slate of high-stakes matchups, with storylines ranging from redemption to domination. The Mariners look to finish off Detroit and advance, the Brewers are eyeing a sweep of the Cubs, while the Yankees and Dodgers both fight to extend their series at home. For bettors, this is one of the most dynamic days of the playoffs so far, every inning, pitching change, and swing could shift the odds dramatically. With elite arms like Bryce Miller, Aaron Nola, and Yoshinobu Yamamoto taking the mound, expect tight contests, live-betting swings, and plenty of opportunities to find value across moneylines, run totals, and prop markets. Here’s your complete guide for today’s MLB playoff action.
Seattle Mariners @ Detroit Tigers | ALDS Game 4
Time: 11:08 AM ET (October 8)
Pitching Matchup: Bryce Miller (SEA) vs Casey Mize (DET)
Series: Mariners lead 2-1
Seattle stands one win away from advancing, while Detroit faces elimination. Bryce Miller’s solid command and strike-throwing ability have given the Mariners consistency in this series. Casey Mize, however, is capable of delivering a strong outing at home if his fastball control holds up.
Also Read: How sportsbooks set their lines, and what bettors can learn
Betting Angle:
- Moneyline: Mariners slightly favored (-120), but Tigers have value as home underdogs (+100).
- Over/Under Runs: 8.0 — the under is worth a look, as both pitchers tend to limit hard contact.
- Prop Bets: Miller over 5.5 strikeouts; Tigers under 4.5 team runs.
Prediction: Mariners close it out in a low-scoring affair, likely around 4-2.
Milwaukee Brewers @ Chicago Cubs | NLDS Game 3
Time: 1:08 PM ET (October 8)
Pitching Matchup: Quinn Priester (MIL) vs Jameson Taillon (CHC)
Series: Brewers lead 2-0
Milwaukee has dominated the series, and a sweep could be on the cards. Quinn Priester brings movement and depth to his pitching, while Taillon will look to keep the Cubs alive. Chicago’s offense has been quiet so far, which could be concerning for bettors banking on a comeback.
Betting Angle:
- Moneyline: Brewers (-130) are a strong play to complete the sweep.
- Run Line: Brewers -1.5 offers value given recent dominance.
- Over/Under Runs: 9.0 — lean under if both pitchers find rhythm early.
Prediction: Brewers complete the sweep with a 5-3 win.
Toronto Blue Jays @ New York Yankees | ALDS Game 4
Time: 3:08 PM ET (October 8)
Pitching Matchup: Louis Varland (TOR) vs Cam Schlittler (NYY)
Series: Blue Jays lead 2-1
Toronto has looked composed under pressure, while the Yankees aim to push the series to a decisive Game 5. Louis Varland has shown steady control and effectiveness in high-leverage innings. Cam Schlittler is less proven at this stage, which could make the difference.
Betting Angle:
- Moneyline: Blue Jays (-115) have the advantage; Yankees at +105 are tempting for value bettors.
- Over/Under Runs: 9.5 — the over is in play, especially in Yankee Stadium.
- Prop Bets: Vladimir Guerrero Jr. to record an RBI; total home runs over 2.5.
Prediction: Toronto edges out another close one, 6-5, to win the series.
Also Read: DraftKings and FanDuel stocks fall following Polymarket’s announcement.
Philadelphia Phillies @ Los Angeles Dodgers | NLDS Game 3
Time: 5:08 PM ET (October 8)
Pitching Matchup: Aaron Nola (PHI) vs Yoshinobu Yamamoto (LAD)
Series: Tied 1-1
This is the marquee matchup of the day. Aaron Nola brings playoff experience, but Yoshinobu Yamamoto’s elite control and pitch movement have been dazzling. Both teams’ offenses can explode, making this one of the best live-betting opportunities of the day.
Betting Angle:
- Moneyline: Dodgers (-135) are slight favorites; Phillies at +115 have upset potential.
- Over/Under Runs: 8.5 — a balanced total that could tilt over if bullpens tire early.
- Prop Bets: Mookie Betts to score a run; total strikeouts under 14.5 combined.
Prediction: Dodgers ride Yamamoto’s brilliance to a 5-3 victory and a 2-1 series lead.
MLB Betting Strategy for October 9
- Lean on Pitching Form: Young arms like Miller and Yamamoto could define the day’s outcomes.
- Series Motivation Matters: Teams facing elimination (Tigers, Cubs, Yankees) tend to play aggressively early.
- Prop Bets Over Totals: Strikeout and RBI markets offer better value than tight moneylines in the playoffs.
- Monitor Weather and Park Factors: Wind at Wrigley and Yankee Stadium can heavily affect total runs.
Indicative Odds Snapshot
(Odds may vary by sportsbook)
| Game | Moneyline (Fav) | Moneyline (Dog) | O/U Runs | Pick |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mariners vs Tigers | SEA -120 | DET +100 | 8.0 | Under |
| Brewers vs Cubs | MIL -130 | CHC +110 | 9.0 | Brewers -1.5 |
| Blue Jays vs Yankees | TOR -115 | NYY +105 | 9.5 | Over |
| Phillies vs Dodgers | LAD -135 | PHI +115 | 8.5 | Dodgers ML |
Focus Keyword:
Meta Description:
FAQs: MLB Playoff Betting (October 9)
Q1: Which MLB games should bettors focus on today?
A1: Key matchups include Mariners vs Tigers (ALDS Game 4), Brewers vs Cubs (NLDS Game 3), Blue Jays vs Yankees (ALDS Game 4), and Phillies vs Dodgers (NLDS Game 3).
Q2: Which teams are most likely to clinch their series?
A2: Mariners and Brewers have the best chance to advance, both leading their series and showing strong form.
Q3: Are today’s games expected to be high-scoring?
A3: Expect mixed results — Mariners vs Tigers may stay low-scoring, while Blue Jays vs Yankees could hit the over.
Q4: What’s the best prop bet for October 9?
A4: Strikeout props for Bryce Miller and Yamamoto, and total home runs over 2.5 in Yankees vs Blue Jays, offer value.
Q5: Should bettors back home or road teams today?
A5: Road teams (Mariners, Brewers, Blue Jays, Dodgers) have been performing well in recent playoff rounds, but home-field advantage remains a key factor in elimination games.
